Half Time Pizza - Toledo, OH

Nick 2 months ago

We ordered a couple pizzas through door dash. The pizza crust was undercooked. Everyone who tried the pizza had a piece or two and did not eat anymore. It tasted like a frozen pizza crust that was heated up in a microwave. The sauce was unremarkable. Not great, not bad. Down the middle. The pizza had a lot of cheese. A plus for some people, a little over the top for me. Simply a bad couple of pizzas. No other way to describe it. Based on this experience, and the number of good pizza places in the area, TWO THUMBS DOWN and will not go back again. 👎👎

Andrew Smeltzer 5 months ago

I love Half Time Pizza. Abe and Rachel are some of the friendliest people you can chat with in a pizza shop. They feel like family. Abe has plenty of experience with making great food and the skill shows on every pie. Rachel’s the friendliest server ever and she goes out of her way to make your party feel comfortable. The two of them together truly do make you want to return not only for their service but their genuine banter. They both have great senses of humor and are just sincerely good people. Their pizza stands out in particular, you'll remember their food long after leaving the Toledo area. If planning on dining in, I would call ahead of time to be sure that seating is available for you. The pizza sauce has a spice to it that makes it stand out from the typical pizza, and it’s what keeps me coming back. It's excellent for groups. As far as kids, the pizza is best for older-elementary to middle-school aged kids to start, just due to the spice that can be somewhat intense for younger kids (it’s worth a try though). Younger kids could reliably enjoy the more mild options of the Garlic Bread with Cheese or an order of meatballs. It is more expensive, but trust me that your money

oh banana 5 months ago

A small restaurant, easy to drive by if it wasnt for the big sign. I got a 9in pizza and it was GREAT. A thick and well done crust so its got a nice crunch to it. Topping go UNDER the cheese so its deceiving that they actually LOAD it with toppings under the cheese. Im a 250lb guy and half the 9in pizza filled me. Thanks in part to the thicker crust and high amounts of cheese. I assume they do mostly to go orders, but the inside was very clean. Red pepper flakes and Parmesan on the table.

Corey Mitchell 2 years ago

Amazing place to visit. Make sure you're hungry or have plenty of people with you. Service was awesome. Found out the sauce was homemade and definitely sets them apart from other pizza places. Almost forgot about this. The crust is a nice balance of thick and thin crust. The way they top it and the way they cook it is good. Not hard like cardboard but not soft that it is doughy.

V A Lew Edited 4 years ago

Lifetime Myles fan. Was very happy when 516 opened but was very sad there was no buffalo. When I saw halftime pizza was a kin to the previous places and had buffalo it was an absolute must to come here. So I was very sad to hear they were out of buffalo. I defaulted to the food lovers/everything but the kitchen sink/big timer. The seating area is limited but very clean. Drink options consists of only bottled products. Really wish there was a fountain drink option. The pizza itself was very good. The sauce has a little bit of zest/kick comparatively. Will be coming back after I verify buffalo is in stock. The tomato bread was fresh.